Bottoms Up Pizza

1700 Dock St.
644-4400
bottomsuppizza.com

Second Place: Mary Angela's Pizzeria

Third Place: Mellow Mushroom

Voters are consistent in this category, year after year preferring the pie at Bottoms Up to the myriad pizza options out there. There's a reason Bottoms Up has been around for nearly a quarter of a century — that thick crust. Carb lovers could scrape the toppings off (hint: Don't) and still be left with a magnificent hunk of well-made bread. Readers who prefer more of a New York-style crust vote for Carytown stalwart Mary Angela's, the go-to pizzeria for a lot of Richmond lifers. Since the chain's anticipated arrival in Carytown, Mellow Mushroom seems to be constantly busy, and also draws fans for its late-night options.