Best Bar, South Side

Readers' Pick

First Place: O’Toole’s Restaurant & Pub

4800 Forest Hill Ave.

Second Place (Tie): South Beach and Southbound

Third Place: Uptown Alley

There’s something to be said for running a steady business since 1966 — yes, that’s 50 years — but owner John O’Toole probably isn’t the one to boast about it. As modest as his little block of Forest Hill Avenue, O’Toole simply says, “We try to put out a good product.” With a clientele that runs from 9 to 90, O’Toole likes to say, “The grandparents come in for lunch, then their kids will have their grandkids in for dinner.” That’s a business model that any bar would emulate. We recommend grabbing a bar seat and a pint in the early afternoon and observing while the regulars roll in. There’s no shortage of characters. Tied in second are a place to party in South Beach, and a place to get a lovely drink with your fine cuisine from the owners of Roosevelt and Heritage, Southbound. In third is the nicest bowling alley combination bar in town, Uptown Alley.

More Categories

More Categories


Arts, Culture and Entertainment

Food and Drink

Goods and Services


People and Places